There are, however, more than enough proxies, including

the withering of the teaching of civics and Daniels’ and his management team’s “gobsmacked” response when, following a course on the foundations of free speech, freshmen told them that they’d never heard the case for free speech.

Daniels’ pen slips at the beginning of his (insightful) discussion of the rise and fall of civics education: spoiler alert, it rises after national traumas like the Civil War and both World Wars.

He writes: “In the fall of 1918, just over a year after President Woodrow Wilson declared war on the German Empire …”. While the president is the commander in chief of the armed forces, Article 1, Section 8 of the Constitution reserves the power to “declare war” to the Congress; what Wilson did on 2 April 1917 was request Congress to declare war.

It is hard not to get caught up in paragraphs on community service and volunteerism as something of a cure for declining civic involvement. But, depressingly, he shows that while “service learning” engages students locally, it does not engage them with America’s system of self-government. In one study, the belief that serving on a jury is an individual’s responsibility actually fell in its prevalence, even as the sense of duty to volunteer rose.

Designing a democracy requirement that avoids the Scylla or the right wing’s call for 1950s-style social norms (ie, white male hegemony) and the Charybdis of the left wing’s critique that the entire edifice of American liberal capitalism is rotten to the core, will not be easy.

One possibility Daniels offers is Stanford University’s (Stanford, California) “Citizenship in the 21st Century”. At the heart of the programme is a “rich array of texts (from indigenous writers to the framers of the US Constitution to the poets of the Harlem Renaissance [eg Langston Hughes])”, as well as discussions of ethics and case studies.

Open science with guardrails

“Embrace open science with guardrails,” is Daniels’ third recommendation. His aim here is to see off the dangers of the right-wing echo chamber (which includes those who attack the science around COVID-19) on the one side, and on the other, radical deconstructionists like Jacques Derrida.

On this last, I think it is worth noting that deconstruction, which I studied while doing my graduate work at McGill University (Montreal, Canada), may have been chic in the 1980s and 1990s but, like most intellectual movements, it’s now a bit long in the tooth.

True, even in the state university system, which educates the largest part of America’s undergraduates, there are courses informed by Derrida’s work. However, there are far more called, to stay with my specialty, English literature, “Shakespeare”, “Milton”, “The Eighteenth-Century Novel”, “The British Romantics”, and others that focus on the Brontës, slave narratives, women’s poetry, post-colonial literature, the Victorian novel. Hardly a “différance”, Derrida’s favourite neologism, to be seen.

Nevertheless, it’s hard not to agree with Daniels’ resolute defence of facts. And, I must add, it is rather fun to read that the sociologist of science, Bruno Latour, asks if it is the duty of scholars, like his earlier self who questioned the validity of the sciences, “to add fresh ruins to fields of ruins” and declare, “I am now the one who naively believes in facts”.

Further, Daniels underscores the dangers private money poses to university research. The fact that scientific journals are now publishing articles about experiments that are unsuccessful is a good omen, he says.

Countering homogeneity

Daniels’ final recommendation, “Reimagine student encounters on campus and infuse debate into campus programming”, returns, in part, to the book’s first chapter which shows how almost all of America’s universities and colleges did whatever they could to remain racially and religiously homogeneous.

Today, while most of these walls have come down, at least officially, Daniels shows that since universities again started allowing freshmen to choose their own roommates in the early 2010s (the practice had been phased out in the 1980s and ’90s), more and more roommates are of similar income and, most importantly, racial groups.

Brought in under the banner of choice, the real impact of this is self-segregation and a noticeable reduction in the number of students who answer ‘yes’ to the question about having friends who are of a different race.

Mutatis mutandis for wealthier students; those who end up rooming with a less well-heeled roommate can console themselves, Daniels shows, with the fact that these poorer students “are less likely to support higher taxes on the wealthy!”

Some schools have responded to this problem by requiring freshmen to live on campus and removing the right of students to choose their roommates.

Equally worrisome for Daniels is the growth of echo chambers. Mercifully, he does not beat the drum about “cancel culture”, the bugaboo of American right-wing media stars, like Fox News’ Tucker Carlson, who conveniently elides the fact that almost every right-wing speaker who has been disinvited to a university is not being silenced – unless his understanding of being silenced is being interviewed on his show in front of three million viewers. At most, Daniels says, there are two dozen disinvitations per year.

Yet, Daniels is concerned that campuses are not arenas of debate. (A reader of his book who kept careful notes would have noted that they hardly ever were.) Room can be made for other voices by, instead of inviting one speaker on a topic, inviting two with opposing points of view.

Daniels’ book, which is worth reading for the facts of American higher education he adduces, is also a cri de coeur for a more inclusive, vibrant and, yes, democratic university or college. While I remain unsure whether such a model can halt America’s slide into “illiberal democracy” at best and open authoritarianism at worst, it is at least worth a try.

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialspider-man-no-way-home-123movies-2021-google-drivejon-watts-online2021,80011

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialtv-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-online-for-free,80013

https://providenceonline.com/stories/onlinefree-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-full-movie-watch-hd,80009

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-online-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies-full-free,80010

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-online-free-marvel-movie-full-download-1080p,80014

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-free-online-streaming-at-home,80005

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-for-free123movie,80006

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now-united-states,80012

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watchfree-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-hd-1080p-googledrive-movies,80008

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-free-online-stream,80007

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-hd-full-movie-online,79995

https://providenceonline.com/stories/how-to-watchfree-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2022-googledrive,80003

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-full-online-free-hd-1080p,79997

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-movie-online-full-free-download-in-hd,79996

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-free-streaming-online-at-home,80002

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-movie-online-free-123,80000

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-full-movies-online-free-4khd,80004

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now-italy,79998

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-homersquo-free-streaming-in-australia-yts,79999

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-english,80001

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-hd-full-movie-online,79986

https://providenceonline.com/stories/mcu-online-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-full-movie-online-free-20-feb-2022-download-here,79985

https://providenceonline.com/stories/official-123movie-spider-man-no-way-home2021-googledrive,79987

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-free-online-streaming-at-home,79988

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-full-movie-online-for-free-in-hd-quality,79989

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-free-streaming,79994

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now-australia,79993

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now-new-zealand,79992

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now-united-kingdomm,79991

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-free-online-stream,79990

https://providenceonline.com/stories/123moviehd-spider-man-no-way-home2021-googledrive-free,79978

https://providenceonline.com/stories/freespider-man-no-way-home-2021-googledrive-movies,79983

https://providenceonline.com/stories/freewatch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies,79982

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialfreespider-man-no-way-home-2021-google-drivefull-hd-english-movie2021,79975

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialspider-man-no-way-home-2021-leaked-on-torrent-siteshd-online2021,79976

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-free-spider-man-no-wa-home-movie-online-480p720p-and-1080p-download-20-february-2022,79984

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-free-online-streaming-at-home,79977

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-free-online-streaming-at-home-2021-googledrive-movies,79981

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now-canada,79980

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now-usa,79979

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies,79965

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies,79966

https://providenceonline.com/stories/official-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-for-free,79974

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialspider-man-no-way-home-2021-online-disneyplus-movie-how-to-stream-2021,79967

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-free-online-streaming-at-home,79971

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-free-online-streaming-at-home,79972

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now,79973

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now-switzerland,79970

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now-united-kingdom,79969

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-free-online,79968

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies,79960

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies,79961

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-spider-man-no-way-home-streaming-2021-googledrive-movies,79964

https://providenceonline.com/stories/freespider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies,79959

https://providenceonline.com/stories/how-to-free-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies,79963

https://providenceonline.com/stories/how-to-watchfree-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies,79962

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-denmark,79957

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-norway,79956

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-switzerland,79955

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-online-free,79958

https://providenceonline.com/stories/how-to-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-free-reddit,79945

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-now-streaming-usa,79948

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-fullmovie-watch-free-full-movies,79947

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-australia,79954

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-france,79949

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-italy,79950

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-new-zealand,79953

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-united-kingdom,79951

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-united-states,79952

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watchfree-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-google,79946

https://providenceonline.com/stories/how-to-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-full-english,79939

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialonlinespider-man-no-way-home-2021-google-drive-720p-english-movie2021,79943

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialspider-man-no-way-home-2021-full-movie-free-reddithd-online2021,79942

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-now-streaming,79937

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-for-free,79940

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-for-free-stream,79941

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-homersquo-free-online-streaming-at-home,79938

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-canada,79935

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-can-i-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-in-usa,79936

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-free-online-stream,79944

https://providenceonline.com/stories/freespider-man-no-way-home-online-for-free-february-20-2021,79933

https://providenceonline.com/stories/freewatch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-streaming-now-france,79931

https://providenceonline.com/stories/freewhere-to-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-free-online-movie,79932

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-now-streaming-canada,79930

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-now-streaming-france,79929

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-streaming-australia,79927

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-streaming-new-zealand,79925

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-streaming-switzerland,79928

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-streaming-united-kingdom,79926

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-movies-for-free-stream,79934

https://providenceonline.com/stories/freedownload-spider-man-no-way-home-2021telugu-hindi-dubbed-movie,79916

https://providenceonline.com/stories/freespider-man-no-way-home-2021-full-movie-download-in-hindi-480p,79915

https://providenceonline.com/stories/freespider-man-no-way-home-2021-yts-torrent-download-yify-movie,79917

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialmovie-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online,79919

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialmovie-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-for-stream,79920

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-free-online-streaming-at-home,79922

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-now-streaming-italy,79924

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2022-full-streaming-united-states,79923

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-full-2021-movie-free,79918

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-for-free-stream,79921

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-720p-480p-and-1080p-download-for-full-free-marvel-movie,79907

https://providenceonline.com/stories/hqmoviespluswatchspider-man-no-way-home-2021-online-movie-full-free4k-download-1080p,79914

https://providenceonline.com/stories/official-hdspider-man-no-way-home-movie-online-free-440p720p-and-1080p-hd-download-20-feb-2022,79913

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialhd-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-online-for-free-at-home,79909

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-freespider-man-no-way-home-2021-hd-online-movie-full-free-720p-480p-and-1080p,79908

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-hq-online-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-full-movie-streaming-free,79912

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-full-movie-online-free123-movies,79906

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-hd-online-movie-full-free-720p-480p-and-1080p-123movies-20,79911

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-full-movie-online-for-free-in-hd-q,79910

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watchmoviesspider-man-no-way-home-2021-online-free-stream,79905

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies,79903

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-spider-man-no-way-home-torrent-magnet-download-trends-on-google,79895

https://providenceonline.com/stories/freespider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-googledrive-movies,79904

https://providenceonline.com/stories/official-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-movie-full-downloadgoogle-drive-mp4-2021,79896

https://providenceonline.com/stories/official-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-movie-online-full-google-drive-hd-2021,79897

https://providenceonline.com/stories/officialfree-watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-for-stream,79898

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-free-streaming,79901

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-free-streaming,79902

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-free-streaming-watch-or-play,79900

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-full-for-free,79899

https://providenceonline.com/stories/free-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-full-english-movie,79892

https://providenceonline.com/stories/how-to-spider-man-no-way-home-free-online-streaming-how-to-watch,79894

https://providenceonline.com/stories/how-to-watchfree-spider-man-no-way-home-streaming-2021-googledrive-movies,79888

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-full-english-movie,79891

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watch-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-full-english-movie,79890

https://providenceonline.com/stories/watchspider-man-no-way-home-2021-full-english-movie,79889

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watchfree-spider-man-no-way-home-2021,79886

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watchfree-spider-man-no-way-home-2021-movie,79885

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watchfree-spider-man-no-way-home-online-2021-google-full-english-movie,79893

https://providenceonline.com/stories/where-to-watchfree-spider-man-no-way-home-streaming-2021-googledrive-movies,79887